Why Taylor Swift Deserves to Be Billboard’s Greatest Pop Star of the 21st Century

Taylor Swift The Eras Tour The Red Era Set” by Paolo Villanueva is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Source

!

There’s a curious thing about ranking pop stars, isn’t there? Who really gets to decide who sits at the top? Is it the numbers, the accolades, or perhaps something more elusive—the ability to transcend time and space through music? There’s a curious thing about ranking pop stars, isn’t there? Who really gets to decide who sits at the top? Is it the numbers, the accolades, or perhaps something more elusive—the ability to transcend time and space through music? When Billboard anointed Beyoncé as the greatest pop star of the 21st century, with Taylor Swift following in second place, I couldn’t help but pause and ask: what makes “greatness”? How much of it is defined by the loud roar of public opinion and how much is rooted in the quiet resonance of an artist’s work—its impact not only on the culture but on the very hearts of those who listen?

If we’re to evaluate Taylor Swift in terms of greatness, we must first admit that “greatness” itself is a fleeting, subjective thing. It is shaped by the listener’s perception—what they bring to the table, what they hear between the lines, what they imagine in the spaces between the notes. So, what does Taylor’s artistry tell us about her place in history? Let’s explore, but do remember: consider this not as the gospel truth, but as my own interpretation, a fleeting moment of perception—one of many possibilities.

The Art of Change: Taylor’s Ever-Shifting Musical Landscape

The thing about Taylor Swift is that she has this extraordinary, almost metaphysical, ability to transform. Her career is an ongoing metamorphosis, an ever-evolving dance with the very nature of sound itself. Who can forget the country tones of Fearless? The glittering pop of 1989? The haunting, introspective moments of Folklore? And then, the raw, unapologetic energy of Reputation? It’s as if with every album, she sheds an old skin to reveal a new dimension of herself. The albums are not just collections of songs—they are windows into different facets of her being.

Each reinvention, while perhaps a business decision in the grand scheme of things, feels personal, intimate. As if Taylor Swift is speaking directly to us from wherever she finds herself, at that very moment. That kind of honesty, that ability to peel back layers and reveal what lies beneath—without fear, without hesitation—feels rare. And perhaps it is this very vulnerability, this fluidity of sound and identity, that allows her to remain so relevant. But, is this fluidity enough to make her the greatest? I leave that to you, the listener, the interpreter, to decide.

The Reclamation of the Self: Mastering Her Narrative

There’s something undeniably profound about Taylor Swift’s ability to reclaim her own story. The whole world watched as she re-recorded her early albums, a move that was less about nostalgia and more about ownership—about taking back what had been taken from her. In doing so, she gave us more than just Fearless (Taylor’s Version); she gave us empowerment in the most subtle of ways. For here was an artist, not just reshaping her own destiny, but redefining what it meant to own one’s narrative.

But why does this matter? Perhaps because in this world, where the music industry often dictates an artist’s fate, Taylor stands apart. She shows us what it means to break free from corporate chains, to demand agency over one’s work. She’s not just an artist; she is a pioneer in the truest sense. And while others may see her re-recordings as a business move, I see it as an act of profound rebellion—a refusal to be silenced by the industry’s invisible forces.

The Language of Emotion: Lyrics that Speak Beyond Words

Then, there are the lyrics. Ah, the lyrics. With every song, Taylor takes us on a journey into her own soul, but in a way that invites us to take that journey with her. How many times have we listened to All Too Well and felt, for a moment, that it was our story? How often have we heard the quiet yearning in Invisible String and been reminded of our own longings—those small, hidden hopes we seldom voice out loud?

Taylor has this ability to speak in the language of the heart, to use words as bridges between herself and us. The pain, the joy, the nostalgia—they aren’t just emotions she’s expressing; they’re emotions we have all felt. In her vulnerability, she has given us permission to feel what we so often hide. But what makes this so extraordinary is that it is not just the words she chooses, but the way she arranges them. The beauty of her lyricism lies in its simplicity—how she can take something so universal, so human, and make it feel personal, as though you are the only one listening.

The Bridge Between Fantasy and Reality: The Eras Tour

As much as Taylor has shaped our emotional world through her music, there’s something almost magical about seeing her perform live. There’s a quiet power in her presence on stage—a sort of calm confidence, as though she knows she’s not just singing to us, but with us. The Eras Tour wasn’t merely a concert; it was an experience, a shared moment of introspection. For those who attended, it wasn’t just about watching a star shine from afar. It was about being part of something, something transcendent, something alive.

And what does that say about Taylor Swift’s place in pop music? It says that her music is not just something we listen to; it is something we live. It becomes a part of our own emotional landscape, connecting us in ways we don’t even fully understand. She doesn’t just create songs—she creates experiences. And in this way, she makes her audience a co-creator of her legacy.

The Greater Question: Is Taylor Swift the Greatest?

So, is Taylor Swift the greatest pop star of the 21st century? The answer lies not in the objective analysis of sales, awards, or accolades, but in the subjective experience of her music. For some, it’s the way she transforms with every album. For others, it’s the raw honesty and self-reclamation that make her stand out. And for many, it’s the emotional connection they feel—whether in a stadium, in their car, or sitting in their room at 3 a.m. The greatness of Taylor Swift isn’t about how loudly the world sings her praises—it’s in the way her music resonates in the quiet, in the spaces between the lyrics, in the moments when we hear a song and feel as though it was written just for us.

In the end, greatness, like music, is subjective. And if Taylor Swift isn’t the greatest pop star of our time, then perhaps greatness itself is something we’re still trying to define. But for now, as long as her music continues to speak to us, to shape us, to make us feel, isn’t that enough?

 Billboard anointed Beyoncé as the greatest pop star of the 21st century, with Taylor Swift following in second place, I couldn’t help but pause and ask: what makes “greatness”? How much of it is defined by the loud roar of public opinion and how much is rooted in the quiet resonance of an artist’s work—its impact not only on the culture but on the very hearts of those who listen?

If we’re to evaluate Taylor Swift in terms of greatness, we must first admit that “greatness” itself is a fleeting, subjective thing. It is shaped by the listener’s perception—what they bring to the table, what they hear between the lines, what they imagine in the spaces between the notes. So, what does Taylor’s artistry tell us about her place in history? Let’s explore, but do remember: consider this not as the gospel truth, but as my own interpretation, a fleeting moment of perception—one of many possibilities.

The Art of Change: Taylor’s Ever-Shifting Musical Landscape

The thing about Taylor Swift is that she has this extraordinary, almost metaphysical, ability to transform. Her career is an ongoing metamorphosis, an ever-evolving dance with the very nature of sound itself. Who can forget the country tones of Fearless? The glittering pop of 1989? The haunting, introspective moments of Folklore? And then, the raw, unapologetic energy of Reputation? It’s as if with every album, she sheds an old skin to reveal a new dimension of herself. The albums are not just collections of songs—they are windows into different facets of her being.

Each reinvention, while perhaps a business decision in the grand scheme of things, feels personal, intimate. As if Taylor Swift is speaking directly to us from wherever she finds herself, at that very moment. That kind of honesty, that ability to peel back layers and reveal what lies beneath—without fear, without hesitation—feels rare. And perhaps it is this very vulnerability, this fluidity of sound and identity, that allows her to remain so relevant. But, is this fluidity enough to make her the greatest? I leave that to you, the listener, the interpreter, to decide.

The Reclamation of the Self: Mastering Her Narrative

There’s something undeniably profound about Taylor Swift’s ability to reclaim her own story. The whole world watched as she re-recorded her early albums, a move that was less about nostalgia and more about ownership—about taking back what had been taken from her. In doing so, she gave us more than just Fearless (Taylor’s Version); she gave us empowerment in the most subtle of ways. For here was an artist, not just reshaping her own destiny, but redefining what it meant to own one’s narrative.

But why does this matter? Perhaps because in this world, where the music industry often dictates an artist’s fate, Taylor stands apart. She shows us what it means to break free from corporate chains, to demand agency over one’s work. She’s not just an artist; she is a pioneer in the truest sense. And while others may see her re-recordings as a business move, I see it as an act of profound rebellion—a refusal to be silenced by the industry’s invisible forces.

The Language of Emotion: Lyrics that Speak Beyond Words

Then, there are the lyrics. Ah, the lyrics. With every song, Taylor takes us on a journey into her own soul, but in a way that invites us to take that journey with her. How many times have we listened to All Too Well and felt, for a moment, that it was our story? How often have we heard the quiet yearning in Invisible String and been reminded of our own longings—those small, hidden hopes we seldom voice out loud?

Taylor has this ability to speak in the language of the heart, to use words as bridges between herself and us. The pain, the joy, the nostalgia—they aren’t just emotions she’s expressing; they’re emotions we have all felt. In her vulnerability, she has given us permission to feel what we so often hide. But what makes this so extraordinary is that it is not just the words she chooses, but the way she arranges them. The beauty of her lyricism lies in its simplicity—how she can take something so universal, so human, and make it feel personal, as though you are the only one listening.

The Bridge Between Fantasy and Reality: The Eras Tour

As much as Taylor has shaped our emotional world through her music, there’s something almost magical about seeing her perform live. There’s a quiet power in her presence on stage—a sort of calm confidence, as though she knows she’s not just singing to us, but with us. The Eras Tour wasn’t merely a concert; it was an experience, a shared moment of introspection. For those who attended, it wasn’t just about watching a star shine from afar. It was about being part of something, something transcendent, something alive.

And what does that say about Taylor Swift’s place in pop music? It says that her music is not just something we listen to; it is something we live. It becomes a part of our own emotional landscape, connecting us in ways we don’t even fully understand. She doesn’t just create songs—she creates experiences. And in this way, she makes her audience a co-creator of her legacy.

⸻

The Greater Question: Is Taylor Swift the Greatest?

So, is Taylor Swift the greatest pop star of the 21st century? The answer lies not in the objective analysis of sales, awards, or accolades, but in the subjective experience of her music. For some, it’s the way she transforms with every album. For others, it’s the raw honesty and self-reclamation that make her stand out. And for many, it’s the emotional connection they feel—whether in a stadium, in their car, or sitting in their room at 3 a.m. The greatness of Taylor Swift isn’t about how loudly the world sings her praises—it’s in the way her music resonates in the quiet, in the spaces between the lyrics, in the moments when we hear a song and feel as though it was written just for us.

In the end, greatness, like music, is subjective. And if Taylor Swift isn’t the greatest pop star of our time, then perhaps greatness itself is something we’re still trying to define. But for now, as long as her music continues to speak to us, to shape us, to make us feel, isn’t that enough?